END OF DAYS! WHITE SORORITY WINS STEP-OFF
END OF DAYS! WHITE SORORITY WINS STEP-OFF
43,842 Views
Zeta Tau Alpha: Epsilon 1st Place Winners Of Sprite Step-Off Challenge 2010
==============================
Mostly White Sorority Wins National Step-Off Competition. Debate Ensues Over Their Participation
From Booker Rising website >http://www.bookerrising.net/2010/02/mostly-white-sorority-wins-national.html
A few days ago, Booker Rising highlighted how Zeta Tau Alpha sorority's chapter at the University of Arkansas last weekend became the first predominantly white sorority to win the national step-off competition....and its $100,000 scholarship prize (watch their winning performance here). As just about every black American knows, black Greek groups take the step-off very seriously, andstep shows have a rich cultural tradition.
The Hilltop, the campus newspaper at Howard University - where most of the historically black fraternities and sororities were founded early last century - wrote an article rounding up people’s reactions to Zeta Tau Alpha sorority’s victory. While some people were happy for the ZTA team, some members of the "Divine Nine" are not pleased at all."This Is A Good Development For American Society/This Is Cool"
Shaunte Russel, a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, from Xenia, Ohio who attended the Atlanta, Ga. event to support the eventually winning Alpha Phi Alpha fraternity step team from Central State University, was impressed by ZTA. “I thought it was pretty amazing that [the Sprite Step Off] had a white step team, and that they performed so well,” she said.“Everyone [is] stuck in the old way of stepping - including only the Divine 9,” said Joshua Taborn, a senior political science and philosophy double major at Howard University. “And because ‘the white people’ won, we’re mad at ourselves.” He added, “We gave them a standing ovation when they stepped, and booed when they won. We’re hypocrites.”An anonymous poster on The Hilltop's website writes: "How can we move past race issues in this country if people are still upset that a predominantly white sorority won a step contest!!!! Seriously, how would you feel if this was the other way around and a predominantly white competition complained that a black group won. Race relations in this country are not a one-way street. The ZTAs won. Next year, bring it. END OF STORY." NewsOne, a black liberal website, writes: "We can’t demand genuine respect for our music, our traditions, and our colleges and then expect people merely to worship from afar. It’s only natural that respect and admiration for historically Black cultural traditions would spawn a desire among people of all races to participate in them. Even if that participation means competition — academic, musical, or otherwise — we should be confident enough in our own abilities that we aren’t compelled to practice exclusion. And in those moments when are out-stepped by a white group, out-rapped by a white emcee, or outperformed in the classroom by a white student, that isn’t a signal that the outsider needs to be thrown out. Rather it means we need to work harder and do better, the same as we would if someone of our own race had bested us." "They Are (Mostly) White Interlopers Stealing Our Culture"“Sprite didn’t do a good job explaining the show; they manipulated the crowd,” Oyetewa Oyerinde, a sophomore sports medicine major at Howard University, told The Hilltop. “I thought the Zetas were more of a showcase. I thought this was a Divine Nine event.”The crowd reaction played a key role in ZTA's win, but some people allege that the show’s outcome was a predetermined one. Various participants backstage asserted that MTV and Sprite took the Cinderella story of the anomalous Zetas and ran with it. They claim that ZTA received a biased amount of television coverage (MTV did a show highlighting teams as a countdown to the big event) and were treated more favorably than other sororities. “I’m upset MTV followed the Zetas around and capitalized on us,” Francesca Hindmon, a senior economics major at Howard University, told The Hilltop. “It seems to have been a setup from jump.” Senior political science major Brittany Reeves was visibly upset at the results. “Sprite used the step off to exploit black culture,” she contended. "Anonymous", a Kappa Alpha Psi fraternity member, posted on The Hilltop's website: "This is history repeating itself. Black creativity and White appropriation, i.e. blues, jazz, rock, hip hop now steppin. Only Black people are to blame. This was a competition and when you whoop and holler over a novelty, you are giving them more credence than deserved. Secondly, the judges are concerned about their image and future income, thus they are more partial to the ebb and flow of the crowd and the novelty of a majority group ($$$$$) who can emulate their culture. Sadly the judges have no idea about the history or art form of steppin, regarding Black fraternities and sororities. There are nuances of the D9 steppin and step shows that many Black people who have not attended college simply to not know or understand. For example, each Fraternity and Sorority had their own steps and it was a taboo to BITE off another Fraternity or Sorority. Unfortunately over the years the steps have become more and more obscured. Even my belowved [sic] Kappas sometimes throw their canes down and God forbid start steppin like Alphas. Does any believe Ludacris would know the difference? This loss was the gain of ZTA, it was acceptable to them to take everyone['s] steps, because simply Black [G]reeks now do it all the time. Maybe next year they will use canes and we can whoop and holler about that as well.""PTA Mom" alleges that ZTA should've been disqualified for doing booty popping at the end of their routine (which she argues violates this competition no-no: "Any dance or step routine that includes nudity, partial nudity, gyrating or simulating sexual activity, or sexually suggestive movements"): "The audience was never told we would help judge. I know the TAU chapter ladies [Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority's chapter at Indiana University, which came in 2nd place] they have a lot of dignity and it showed on stage. They would not have thought of breaking the rules and doing a sexually explicit move as the other team did." ZTA Member Vs. Divine 9 SupportersA Zeta Tau Alpha member posts a comment on The Hilltop's website: "To address the comments above; the Divine 9 are responsible for teaching us to step, therefore why would you be surprised when we beat you? You say you are the best, but cannot handle defeat in a humble way. No Zeta set out to prove anything by entering this competit[i]on, the point of this competition was to step. And that is all we have done. The creed of Zeta Tau Alpha says to be 'humble in success and without bitterness in defeat.' That is exactly what the Zeta's have accomplished by winning this competition.""Can Not Believe!" responds: "In rebuttal to the obvious Zeta Tau Alpha who wrote the response, there was no humility or reverence paid or shown to the organization that taught you. Furthermore, ALL THE STEPS DONE BELONG TO THE DIVINE 9 ORGANIZATIONS. The steps done by this organization was performed by both sororities and f[r]aternities. Also though Sprite let you all step, it was our organizations that were advised and sold tickets. Furthermore, as you claim that the money received was for schol[a]rship, I am expecting to hear that the UNCF (the United Negro College [F]und) the National Pan-Hellenic [C]oun[ci]l and the Historical[ly] Black Colleges and Universities will be getting their checks in the mail.""Anonymous", an assumed Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority member, comments on how the AKA chapter at the University of Arkansas taught the ZTA chapter how to step 15 years ago: "I TOTALLY AGREE WITH 'CAN'T BELIEVE'S STATEMENT'....we can't keep anything to ourselves......DAMN SHAME!!!! I AM PISSED!!!! I'M ALSO ASHAMED THAT MY SORORITY TAUGHT THEM!!!!"==============================
Can We At Least Keep Stepping to Ourselves?
Nope. We've got to share our traditions. Just like white sorority Zeta Tau Alpha will share their win with Alpha Kappa Alpha.
- | Posted: February 26, 2010 at 6:35 AM
It’s the closest thing to Armageddon that many Black Greeks have seen since Laurence Fishburne’s character, Dap, ran around the fictitious Mission College campus yelling, “Wake Up!” in the classic movie,School Daze. Stepping, a bastion of black Greek life, has just undergone a revolution, and some black folks are pretty ticked off about it.
It all started on Feb. 20 when Zeta Tau Alpha Sorority, a predominantly white sorority, entered the Sprite Step Off National Step Competition in Atlanta, and beat three National Pan-Hellenic Council sororities: Alpha Kappa Alpha, Delta Sigma Theta and Zeta Phi Beta, winning the $100,000 first prize. While many black Greeks gave the ZTAs their due, the blowback was immediate from a lot of angry black Greeks who couldn’t believe a white sorority could honestly beat black sororities.
The Sprite Step Off, broadcast on MTV2, distributed $1.5 million in prize money via regional competitions to winning step teams from around the country. With musical guests like Lupe Fiasco and Ludacris, this was the first national stepping competition to gain such widespread exposure, and the finals in Atlanta were highly anticipated.
And while the nine African-American fraternities and sororities signed a licensing agreement with Sprite, earning an estimated $75,000 per organization, there was nothing in their agreement that prevented a non-African-American fraternity or sorority from competing. Enter Zeta Tau Alpha Sorority from the University of Arkansas.
Immediately after word got out that Zeta Tau Alpha had won, Twitter and Facebook blew up with accusations that Sprite was biased in favor of the white sorority. Others claimed that it was a stunt for MTV2, which broadcasted the contest.
Some postings even said white organizations shouldn’t be allowed to participate in stepping competitions in the first place, since stepping is a black Greek cultural tradition. Others accused Zeta Tau Alpha of being the equivalent of modern-day minstrels, debasing the art form by their very presence.
Then on Feb. 25, Sprite announced on Facebook that they had discovered "a scoring discrepancy" that they could not resolve. They decided to make ZTA and AKA co-winners of the competition, giving each organization $100,000 in prize money.
But in the grand scheme of things, that outcome is a minor detail. There's a bigger principle at stake here. In 25 years as an Alpha, I've helped judge countless stepping contests. And although judging is subjective, there's no way anyone can objectively state that the ZTAs didn't perform to a standard which would merit getting first prize in the Step Off. (See the videos below of the winners and runners-up, and tell me if I’m wrong.)
The problem with the arguments presented by the critics is that they tend to gloss over the question of whether the Zeta Tau Alpha steppers were actually better than their competition. Instead, most of the criticism has been reactionary and sought to deny Zeta Tau Alpha the opportunity to compete based solely on their skin color.
By doing that, black Greeks do a disservice to our historic legacy. African-American fraternities and sororities were born in circumstances that sought to combat judgments based on race. And to do the same as those who would deny us opportunity, based on the notion that we’re somehow protecting our black cultural integrity, is morally bankrupt.
-
The founders of Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity were denied access to the campus library at Indiana University because they were black. The founders of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority protested when white women ordered them to the back of a women’s suffrage march in Washington, D.C.
Too often, black Greeks place too much significance on stepping, and overemphasize its historical weight. We claim that the stepping tradition was passed down from some ancient African traditions. (It wasn’t.) We claim that we’ve been doing it for nearly a century. (We haven’t.)
According to Philander Smith College president Dr. Walter Kimbrough, author of Black Greek 101 and the person who has done the most research on the origins of stepping, stepping is a relatively recent tradition, growing out of probate shows of the 1970s.
Black cultural traditions like stepping are always nurtured within our community, exposed to the outside world as an artistic gift, and then adapted and adopted by others who want to participate. The idea that our traditions can remain purely “black” is folly.
Black Greeks, and African Americans in general, shouldn’t fear appropriation of our art forms. We should instead be good stewards of our own traditions, work to improve them and demand respect by anyone, black or not, who attempts to bring tribute to it.
With that in mind, anyone watching Zeta Tau Alpha Sorority’s performance would not only agree that they respected the art form, but that they also gave a show that is worthy of a win. And for that, black Greeks should remember our roots and congratulate them on a job well done. Because to not do so says more about us as black Greeks than it does about Zeta Tau Alpha as a white sorority.
Lawrence C. Ross Jr. is the author of The Divine Nine: The History of African American Fraternities and Sororities and a brother of Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity, Inc. Follow him on Twitter.
Become a fan of The Root on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter.
==============================