LOUISIANA INCARCERATED
How we built the world's prison capital
__________________________
Louisiana taxpayers
finance a prison bonanza:
James Gill
Published: Sunday, May 27, 2012, 7:47 AM
We have taken to calling it the prison industry because it is a major economic force in Louisiana.
Ellis Lucia, The Times-Picayune
Louisiana sends more people to prison, per capita, than any other state in the U.S. or any country.
Locking up more of our citizens than any other place on earth may cost billions, but there are compensations. Look at all the jobs we create.
That is the conventional wisdom, which is to say utter nonsense. A bloated prison population has no economic upside whatsoever.
That is not the way it seems in rural Louisiana, where the local hoosegow may be far and away the biggest employer, while the sheriff makes enough profit on housing state prisoners to buy a new fleet of patrol cars. And don't tell a private prison operator this is not a thriving industry.
Last year Gov. Bobby Jindal's plan to sell the prison in Avoyelles Parish to private operators was derailed amid protests that employees would see their pay and benefits reduced with devastating consequences for the local economy. Hands off our prisons is the rallying cry in north Louisiana.
It must, indeed, seem like magic in some depressed backwater when the state plops down a new prison and jobs are suddenly available. The economic benefits are there for all to see.
But what seems like magic is always sleight of hand. Behind the scenes the government is just taking money out of one pocket, the taxpayer's, and putting it in another. Money spent on prisons could have provided as much, and probably more, economic stimulus if the government had let us keep it.
Taxpayers have no desire to keep all of it, of course. A five-minute conversation with the average Angola inmate will convince the most bleeding of hearts that penitentiaries are a prudent investment. We'll happily pay whatever it costs to administer condign punishment and put violent offenders out of circulation for a long time.
But Louisiana did not get to be the corrections capital of the world by taking a utilitarian approach to criminal justice. Not only do we send many up the river for penny-ante offenses, but, thanks to mandatory minimums and multiple billing, sentences are savagely out of whack. It cannot conceivably be argued that society's interests require one in every 86 of its members to be confined.
That may be double the national rate, which comfortably leads even the most benighted of foreign countries, but the black men of New Orleans can barely imagine such a liberal regime. One in 14 of them is behind bars, and a similar number is on parole or probation.
While we are the quickest to lock up offenders, we spend the least per capita to feed and house them. The system is so inhumane and racist that its sins could not be palliated however many jobs were created.
But for every new screw hired in Richland Parish, at least one poor slob in, say, Terrebonne joins the unemployment rolls. The only way for government to create a job is to confiscate money that could generate economic activity elsewhere.
Certainly, that can be a boon in the boonies, where workers might otherwise be obliged to relocate in search of a livelihood. Good for them that they can live out their lives on the ancestral sod, but it is only possible so long as the rest of us provide a subsidy by underwriting a boondoggle. Given our druthers, we might prefer to keep the money in our pockets or divert it to some more pressing government purpose, such as paying off those "unfunded liabilities" in the pension system that threaten to bankrupt the state.
If building prisons really created jobs out of nothing, we could build one in every corner of the state to achieve full employment. Don't think it would work.
Our prisons are adept at turning minor offenders into career criminals. Most prisoners spend the entire day staring at walls or picking up tips from other inmates. Hardly any attempt is made to train or rehabilitate, yet, if they fail to find honest employment on their release, we'll lock them up again.
Their misery will always mean profit for a more fortunate few. Just let us not pretend this is an industry with any economic benefits whatsoever.
•••••••
James Gill is a columnist for The Times-Picayune. He can be reached at jgill@timespicayune.com.
By MARGIE MASON 05/31/12 11:05 PM ET